Skip to content
Plant-Based Papa

Vegan Scalloped Potatoes (No Blending & Super Creamy)

Published

Updated

Jump to Recipe
Baked vegan scalloped potatoes with a golden-brown, bubbly top sprinkled with black pepper, in a red and white ceramic baking dish on a white marble surface.

Intro

Scalloped potatoes are the ultimate comfort food. They’re great for special occasions like Thanksgiving, Christmas, and Easter, but they’re just as good for a home-cooked meal on a random weeknight. Most scalloped potato recipes out there are absolutely loaded with dairy: cream, cheese, and butter. All delicious, but not very plant-based, so people with dairy allergies, or people like us who are vegan, can’t enjoy them to the fullest.

That’s where this recipe comes in. You won’t miss the dairy, because it’s delicious without it. Dare we say it’s equal to its very dairy-heavy counterpart. And unlike most vegan scalloped potato recipes out there, this one requires absolutely no blending, and it still turns out super creamy, just like you’d expect.

This is the side dish that earns a spot on our holiday table every year. It pairs perfectly with our Vegan Stuffed Roast or our Hickory Smoked “Ham” for Thanksgiving, Christmas, or Easter dinner, and it’s just as good next to a simple weeknight main.

Now let’s talk about nutrition, because that’s really important to us.

Nutrition

While scalloped potatoes definitely aren’t a health food, you can feel a lot better about eating these than the dairy-based version. Because this recipe is 100% plant-based, it has absolutely no cholesterol, while a non-vegan recipe has 87mg per serving. That’s almost half of the daily value in one serving, and this is just a side dish!

Now the rest of the numbers. One serving of ours has 252 calories, 10.3g of protein, 32.6g of carbs, and 6.4g of fat. The dairy-based version has 425 calories, 12g of protein, 29g of carbs, and a whopping 29g of fat (18g of it saturated and 1g trans fat). Ours has slightly less protein, but almost 23g less fat per serving is crazy.

And that’s not even counting the rest of the nutrition, where ours comes out ahead across the board: 0.6g more iron, more vitamin D, over 2g more fiber, and almost 150mg more potassium. Those are just the notable ones from the dairy version. Ours also has over 100% of your daily value of all the B vitamins except B5, plus large amounts of folate, vitamin C, copper, magnesium, manganese, phosphorus, and much more. It even tops many other vegan recipes in terms of nutrition. See the nutrition panel for the full breakdown.

Now let’s get into the ingredients:

What You’ll Need

  • Yukon Gold potatoes: the star of the recipe, and the potato you choose makes all the difference. Yukon Golds give you a super creamy, delicious texture that you won’t get from russets. See the FAQ and notes for other potatoes you can use.
  • Plain, cultured vegan yogurt: the other star, in our opinion. The thicker, the better! It sounds a little weird, but it gives the potatoes the creaminess and slight tang you’d get from heavy cream, and it takes this recipe to the next level. We love using our homemade vegan yogurt, but store-bought works too.
  • Plant milk and no-chicken or vegetable broth: the liquid base of the sauce.
  • Nutritional yeast: we love it for the nutrition, and it also amps up the savory, almost cheesy quality of the sauce.
  • Yellow onion, garlic, and vegan butter: sautéed together to build a savory base for the sauce.
  • All-purpose flour (or cornstarch for gluten-free): thickens the sauce.
  • Salt and ground black pepper: season generously, and that’s pretty much it!

Tips for Success

  • The more even your potato slices are, the better your scalloped potatoes will be. We like to slice ours on a mandoline for precise slices about ⅛ of an inch thick. If you don’t have one, a kitchen knife works, just try to cut the slices as evenly as you can.
  • Like most of our potato based recipes, we like soaking them in ice water for about 15-30 minutes to remove excess starches from them, resulting in a creamier scalloped potato.
  • Since we don't make a traditional roux using equal parts oil and flour you need to be very slow in adding the liquid. We first add the yogurt a little bit at a time, mixing completely before adding more, then the plant milk then the broth. This helps create the smoothest, lump free sauce. If your sauce is lumpy, it's because you added the liquid either too fast or in the wrong order.
  • Make sure your plant milk and yogurt are fairly neutral in flavor, or at least make sure one of them is, so they don’t overpower the potatoes. For example, we wouldn’t use both a coconut yogurt and a coconut plant milk, because the potatoes would end up tasting like coconut.
  • Stick a fork or toothpick through the potatoes before pulling them out of the oven. It should go through smoothly. The last thing you want is crunchy, undercooked potatoes, so err on the side of caution and bake a little longer if you’re not sure they’re done.

How to Store

Making ahead: Bake it covered for 45 to 50 minutes, then transfer it to the refrigerator wrapped in plastic wrap or with an airtight lid. When you’re ready, take it out and finish baking uncovered in the oven.

Refrigerator: Store leftovers covered in the refrigerator for up to 4 days.

Freezer: Bake according to the recipe, cool completely, then cover tightly and freeze in a freezer-safe container for up to 3 months. When you’re ready to eat, thaw in the refrigerator, then heat up as desired.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can this recipe be made gluten-free?

Yes! Instead of making a roux with flour and butter, make a slurry from 2 tablespoons of cornstarch and 2 tablespoons of cool broth or plant milk. Add the slurry once you’ve added the yogurt, broth, and plant milk to the sauce.

Can this recipe be made oil free?

Yes, simply omit the butter and cook the onions and garlic in a bit of broth instead. Make sure to really add the liquid slowly and stir until full combined before adding more though to avoid a lumpy sauce.

I don’t have vegan yogurt. What can I use instead?

Vegan sour cream also works. If you don’t have that, you can make vegan buttermilk from unsweetened plant milk and a liquid acid (see our Vegan Buttermilk recipe for exact proportions and tips). You can also just use another cup of plant milk, but keep in mind it will be less creamy.

What if I don’t have a mandoline?

Just cut your potatoes with a sharp knife into even slices about ⅛ of an inch thick. The thinner and more even your slices are, the better your scalloped potatoes will be. If your slices are thicker, you may need to increase the cooking time.

Ready to give it a try? Here’s the full recipe:

Vegan Scalloped Potatoes (No Blending & Super Creamy)

Super creamy vegan scalloped potatoes with no blending and no dairy. A Thanksgiving, Christmas and Easter favorite with 23g less fat and no cholesterol.

Prep
25 min
Cook
1 hr 30 min
Cool
5 min
Total
2 hr 0 min
Servings
8 (1 cup each)
Difficulty
Medium

Ingredients

Instructions

  1. Using a mandoline (or sharp knife) slice 3 lb Yukon Gold Potatoes 1/8th of an inch thick then place in a bowl of ice water to rest for at least 15 minutes (preferably 30).

  2. Pre-heat your oven to 350°F and bring out a 9 x 13 inch baking dish.

  3. While your potato slices are resting in ice water, dice 1 Large Onion and 5 Garlic Cloves into small sized pieces.

  4. In a small pot melt 2 tbsp Vegan Butter (see notes for oil free) then add to the pot the diced onions and sauté until translucent. Add the minced garlic to the pot and cook about another minute until fragrant.

  5. Stir in 1/4 cup All-Purpose Flour (see notes for GF), 1/2 cup Nutritional Yeast, 1 & 1/2+ tsp Salt and 1+ tsp Ground Black Pepper. Slowly mix in 1 cup Plain Vegan Yogurt (see notes for substitutions), making sure that all the liquid is fully absorbed before adding more and repeating the process with 1 cup Plain Plant Milk and 1 cup No-Chicken or Vegetable Broth. See Tips for Success to avoid lumps.

  6. Bring the sauce to a simmer and let simmer for a couple minutes until it thickens.

  7. Rinse off your potato slices and pat them dry thoroughly with a towel, then place about 1/3rd of the potatoes in a layer in the baking dish. Pour about 1/3rd of your sauce over the potatoes, then optionally sprinkle additional salt and pepper over the layer and then repeat the layering process two more times.

  8. Cover the baking dish with aluminum foil then bake covered for 45-50 minutes. Uncover and bake an additional 40-45 minutes or until potatoes are golden brown and you can easily stick a fork/toothpick through the center.

  9. Take the potatoes out of the oven and let cool for at least 5 minutes before serving (preferably 15).

Nutrition (per serving)

Calories
252 kcal
Protein
10.3 g
Carbs
32.6 g
Fat
6.4 g
Fiber
5.2 g
Sugar
2.8 g
Sodium
586.9 mg
Vit. B12
7.6 mcg

Notes & Tips

  • Feel free to use any baking dish that you have on hand, just make sure if you're using a much smaller baking dish that you increase the covered cooking time because it takes longer to fully cook the more layers there are and vice versa.
  • To make this recipe oil free simply sauté your onions and garlic in 2 tablespoons of broth, being careful that it doesn't stick to the pan. Keep in mind if you cooking you're using broth instead of butter, you need to very slowly add your liquid to the flour mixture because it has a tendency to form lumps a lot easier than if you used butter.
  • This recipe works best with Yukon Gold (or yellow potatoes), but if all you have on hand is a thick skinned potato like russet potatoes, it's recommended that you peel your potatoes before slicing them because the skin of russet potatoes is not very appetizing.
  • For gluten free you can substitute 2 tablespoons of cornstarch in place of the all-purpose flour. To do this combine the cornstarch with 2 tablespoons of plant-milk or broth to make a cornstarch slurry. Once all of your other ingredients have been added to the sauce you can add the cornstarch slurry then cook according to the rest of the instructions.
  • If you don't have vegan yogurt on hand, here are our favorite substitutions in order:
    • 1 cup of Vegan Sour Cream
    • 1 cup of Vegan Buttermilk
    • 1 cup of a creamy plain Plant Milk (like soy or cashew)

You may also like

Reviews

No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!